NES STILL BEHIND ON TREE TRIMMING

Nashville Electric Service fell short of its tree trimming goal again in September, trimming 80 miles of vegetation against a goal of more than 120, nash.news reports. As of Oct. 23, the utility had trimmed 62 percent of what it planned for this point in the fiscal year. NES says it has added planners and trimmers and trimmed 67 miles just last week.

Source: nash.news, our news partner
Read nash.news

Questions We Have: Will NES catch up before winter storm season, and which neighborhoods are furthest behind?


🧅 PEEL THE ONION
Why NES Keeps Falling Behind on Tree Trimming

NTN goes a layer deeper · By Neil Orne

Nashville Electric Service is behind on tree trimming again. In September, crews trimmed about 80 miles against a goal of more than 120, according to nash.news. As of Oct. 23, NES had finished 62 percent of the work it planned for this point in the fiscal year.

There is some good news inside those numbers. A month ago the picture was worse. At its September board meeting, NES reported 89 miles trimmed through August against a target of 258, about 34 percent. NES says it has since added planners and trimmers, and crews trimmed 67 miles just last week.

To understand why every one of those miles matters, it helps to go back to January.

The Nashville ice storm left more than 230,000 NES customers without power in freezing temperatures, some for more than a week. The author of this piece was one of them, without power for 12 days. NES leaders said trees were the biggest problem. Whole trees fell across lines, and others split apart under the weight of the ice. CEO Teresa Broyles-Aplin told her board that some of that damage is hard to prevent, but that “tree trimming is incredibly effective” at reducing the risk of whole trees coming down.

The warning came before the storm. An internal NES risk management audit dated Nov. 20, 2025, two months before the ice, rated “inadequate vegetation management and maintenance” as a high risk that could increase the frequency and duration of outages. In its response, NES said tree work had been placed under new management in fiscal year 2024 and that “unforeseen challenges prevented trimming sufficient miles” in 2025.

NewsChannel 5 Investigates found NES spent nearly $7 million less on tree trimming from fiscal year 2023 to 2025. Broyles-Aplin said the budget was never cut and has gone up every year, and that a vendor change a few years ago likely brought better pricing. A budget can grow while actual spending shrinks, which is why it would help the public to see both numbers side by side.

After the storm, NES changed course. In February it raised the required clearance between trees and power lines from 10 feet to 15 and said it would use LiDAR, laser mapping from the air, to build a 3D map of its whole system. In May it announced it would trim the entire city every three years instead of every four, and switched from cutting “ground to sky” to a horseshoe shape that leaves more of the tree standing. NES says it finished its old four-year cycle by June 30. The board also approved $44 million for storm response improvements and $9 million to test burying power lines in four neighborhoods.

Then the new program got off to a slow start. NES told its board in September that new contractors were still building up their crews and that a vendor processing the LiDAR data took longer than expected to deliver trimming work plans. The board responded by letting the CEO sign up to $15 million in additional trimming contracts without waiting for the October meeting, a move NES said would buy about two weeks of extra work before winter.

Speed is only half the challenge. Many neighbors say crews have left trees badly cut or leaning toward homes, sometimes with little notice and a bill to remove what was left. Metro Council asked NES in May to pause the new approach. NES declined, saying a pause would raise the risk of outages during storm season. In July, the Council asked NES to show data proving the tougher trimming actually reduces outages. NES says it is collecting that data, and a Council committee expects an update in March. The Nashville Tree Conservation Corps worries a rush to catch up could mean more damage, and says NES was unsure whether its new contractors are certified.

The independent review of the storm response, a 133-page report by PA Consulting released in June, focused mostly on planning, command structure, communication and how slowly NES called for outside help. It estimated earlier outside aid could have cut restoration time by two to five days. On trees, it credited the work NES has done since the storm and said that work could be expanded.

Looking back, the missed opportunities are clear. The utility knew in November 2025 that trimming was a high risk and that it was behind. Spending had dropped. And the new program, announced in February, was still waiting on contractors and mapping data in September, the start of a new storm season.

Now the questions that matter most. Will NES reach its trimming goal before the worst of winter? Which neighborhoods are furthest behind? Who are the new contractors, and are their crews certified? And will NES publish its progress and outage data so families can see for themselves whether the new approach is working?

Trees and power lines will always share Nashville’s streets. The real test is whether the plan to keep them apart can move faster than the next storm.

Sources: nash.news, our news partner (Oct. 29, 2026); WSMV (Sept. 23, Sept. 23, Aug. 11, May 27); NewsChannel 5 Investigates (Feb. 3); FOX 17 (Feb. 5); Nashville Banner (Feb. 26); Nashville Scene (June).


Discover more from Not The News

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.